The article addresses the problem of procedural defectiveness of administrative acts, which has not yet been examined extensively in Russian legal literature. The article provides a definition of procedural defects of administrative acts and offers a brief comparative overview of the issue in legal systems of France, Germany, the UK, Bulgaria and Poland. The paper demonstrates historical development of the theme in the Russian legal doctrine while special attention is paid to the analysis of the current Russian law and application thereof. By a number of examples the author substantiates the thesis that contemporary administrative law of Russia contains sufficient ground for theoretical conceptualization of the notion of substantial procedural defects of administrative acts. The author puts forward a set of criteria for classification of procedural defects into substantial and non-substantial and argues that such differentiation constitutes a particular manifestation of general legal trends.
Defect, procedure, administrative act, material breach, the right to be heard, the concept of substantial procedural defects, administrative law.
1. Alder J. Constitutional and Administrative Law. Palgrave Macmillan, 2009.
2. Endicott T. Administrative Law. Oxford University Press, 2011.
3. Jones B., Thompson K. Administrative Law in the United Kingdom. Administrative Law of the European Union, Its Member States and the United States. A comparative Analysis / eds. by R. Seerden, F. Stroink. Antwerpen - Groningen, Intersentia, 2002.
4. Administrativno-protsessual´noe pravo Germanii = Verwaltungsrechtsschutz in Deutschland. Per. s nem. / sost., predisl. V. Bergmann. M., 2007.
5. Administrativnyy protsess: uchebnik dlya bakalavriata i magistratury / pod red. M. A. Shtatinoy. M., 2014.
6. Andreev D. S. Defektnye administrativno-pravovye akty: avtoref. dis.... kand. yurid. nauk. M., 2011.
7. Andreev D. S. Ponyatie defektnogo administrativno-pravovogo akta. Administrativnoe pravo i protsess. 2010. № 6.
8. Vedel´ Zh. Administrativnoe pravo Frantsii. M., 1973.
9. Galligan D., Polyanskiy V. V., Starilov Yu. N. Administrativnoe pravo: istoriya razvitiya i osnovnye sovremennye kontseptsii. M., 2002.
10. Deppe Y. O regulirovanii deyatel´nosti administrativnykh organov v FRG. Administrativnaya reforma v Respublike Uzbekistan: opyt i problemy pravovogo regulirovaniya. Tashkent, 2008.
11. Durdenevskiy V. Teoriya nedeystvitel´nosti administrativnogo akta vo Frantsii. Yuridicheskie zapiski Demidovskogo yuridicheskogo litseya. Vyp. I-II. Yaroslavl´, 1914.
12. Evtikhiev A. F. Zakonnaya sila aktov administratsii. Lyublin, 1911.
13. Kapitan D. Obshchie printsipy administrativnogo protsessa vo Frantsii. Administrativnye protsedury i kontrol´ v svete evropeyskogo opyta / pod red. T. Ya. Khabrievoy, Zh. Marku. M., 2011.
14. Kononov P. I. Osnovnye kategorii administrativnogo prava i protsessa. M., 2013.
15. Kontrol´ za deyatel´nost´yu gosudarstvennoy administratsii vo Frantsii. M., 1994.
16. Lazarev B. M. Ponyatie i vidy upravlencheskikh protsedur. Ikh rol´ v mekhanizme gosudarstvennogo upravleniya. Upravlencheskie protsedury / otv. red. B. M. Lazarev. M., 1988.
17. Lazarov K. Kriterii razgranicheniya nichtozhnykh i osporimykh administrativnykh aktov. Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo. 1988. № 3.
18. Mitskevich L. A. Osnovy administrativnogo prava Germanii. Krasnoyarsk, 2008.
19. Novoselov V. I. Zakonnost´ aktov organov upravleniya. M., 1968.
20. Obi Zh.-B. Administrativnyy spor. Obshchie svedeniya ob administrativnom prave Frantsii. M., 1993.
21. Raz´´yasneniya po voprosam administrativnogo prava, prepodannye po delam Pervogo obshchego sobraniya Pravitel´stvuyushchego Senata, voskhodivshim na rassmotrenie konsul´tatsii, pri Ministerstve yustitsii uchrezhdennoy, za period s iyunya 1905 g. po iyun´ 1908 g. / sost. I. D. Mordukhay-Boltovskoy. SPb., 1909.
22. Staros´tsyak E. Pravovye formy administrativnoy deyatel´nosti. M., 1959.
23. Tikhomirov Yu. A. Administrativnye protsedury: doktrina i praktika. Administrativnye protsedury i kontrol´ v svete evropeyskogo opyta / pod red. T. Ya. Khabrievoy, Zh. Marku. M., 2011.
24. Tsiko Ya. Osnovy zakonodatel´stva ob administrativnykh protsedurakh v Germanii. Ezhegodnik publichnogo prava - 2014: Administrativnoe pravo: sravnitel´no-pravovye podkhody. M., 2014.
